Massey's Pizza Delaware

3.6 ( 232 reviews )
$10–20
219 S Sandusky St, Delaware, OH 43015, United States
+1 740-513-3700

Massey's Pizza Delaware, located at 219 S Sandusky St, has quickly become a celebrated dining spot in Ohio. The restaurant earns rave reviews for its diverse pizza buffet, which features a variety of choices complemented by fresh salads, highlighting their commitment to quality and variety. Customers appreciate the warm ambiance and friendly staff, making every visit special.

Highlighted dishes include the traditional pepperoni pizza, praised for its generous toppings and balanced flavors, as well as unique specialty pizzas like The Godfather, likened to a lasagna with its filling and delectable layers. Reviewers also commend the quality of the wings and Italian subs, noting both for their generous size and flavor profile. Notably, the cinnamon pizza has won over the sweet tooth of many patrons.

Delivery service is prompt, ensuring meals arrive hot and fresh, but nothing beats enjoying a hot pizza right out of the oven at the restaurant. The family-run approach adds a personal touch, making it not just a meal, but an experience filled with warmth and care. Massey's is not just about pizza; it's about community, making each visit a delightful occasion. A trip to Massey’s is sure to bring back sincere smiles and sturdy appetites!

Amenities and More

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Offers kerbside pickup
    • Has no-contact delivery
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Offerings
    • Serves alcohol
    • Serves beer
    • Serves comfort food
  • Dining options
    • Serves lunch
    • Serves dinner
    • Has catering
    • Serves dessert
    • Has seating
  • Crowd
    • Family friendly
  • Payments
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards
  • Children
    • Good for kids
  • Parking
    • Plenty of parking

Reviews For Massey's Pizza Delaware

Rajakumar M
Jun 25,2025
Simply superb! Lot of varieties on pizza buffet with salads
Gary Yurco
Jun 23,2025
Picking up pizza, wings & garlic bread. Decided to have a beer while waiting. Tried the Alaskan Amber draft. It was very good. Son had Yuengling draft. Staff very friendly and courteous. Love Massey's. Don't have near my home. This location is about 25 minute drive but worth it for us. Every once in awhile of course. Wings were very good. Fairly large in size. Needed.much more hot sauce for my liking, barbecue wings had plenty of sauce. Not crispy but about 5 minutes on each side in the broiler crisped.them up a bit. The traditional pep pizza is out favorite. Can't go wrong with that choice.
Terri K
Jun 12,2025
Ordered 2 cinnamon pizzas, one Stromboli, one large pepperoni, mushroom and extra cheese, and two 2L sodas for delivery. First time ordering from Massey’s ever. Definitely wasn’t disappointed! Pizza was great, Stromboli was great and they even included the two xtra sauce I requested in the comments because I didn’t realize you could order extra separately! Cinnamon pizza were great as well. Toppings were very generous, not over baked and arrived still hot to us! Very impressed! We will definitely order again. Very satisfied!
Ryan Hester
May 1,2025
We tried two of the specialty pizzas and The Godfather. The specialty pizzas remind me of Ben & Jerry’s flavors. The flavors seem to be carefully and considerately balanced. The Godfather was like eating a lasagna. It’s thick, filling and tasty! Toppings are plentiful and of excellent quality. Seasonings are on point. Crust wasn’t sugary or yeasty and was pleasant to eat. My wife who usually discards crust actually ate hers. Yes, it’s a little expensive, but the quality is worth it.
Michael Swickrath
Apr 3,2025
We were at Massey’s yesterday. As always, the order-in food is amazing. The delivery is good but little beats a hot Massey’s pizza right out of the oven. I also ordered and received the best Italian sub I have ever had. We the wings as well and were super impressed with the quality of the chicken. Not of this compels me to take the time to write a review though... what was special was that this is a family-run location and they clearly understood we were there as a family and they treated us with exceptional care and gratitude to share food with the customers they truly value. They interacted with our kids and even gave them coloring pages that they could hang up after lunch. It was such a fun experience with great food and caring. Thank you Massey’s of Delaware!
James Wyatt
Mar 25,2025
My last trip was fantastic. We had a phone order for pick up. It was ready ahead of schedule and exactly how my wife likes hers. Massey's cauliflower crust is the only one she'll eat. Great job guys!
Haley M
Mar 23,2025
Massey's is one of my FAVORITE pizza places & they now offer cauliflower crust! Which is perfect for me. My experience EVERY time I have gotten pizza from the Delaware location has been very pleasant. Justin was super kind and helpful this evening. Also, the pizza NEVER disappoints. Some of Massey's reviews are critical for this location unfortunately, but I would reccomend giving them a try and forming your own opinion. Thank you guys for a great experience, and mouth watering food as always! You got my business for life :)
Mike Davis
Mar 22,2025
Visited the Delaware location today for lunch with a friend. A positive visit from beginning to end! Every associate we came in contact with were very pleasant, especially the manager, Donald. Even while dining I overheard him taking an order over the phone, again pleasant and professional. The parking lot and restroom were both spotless. Lastly, the reason why we came...the pizza! It was awesome! Abundant with pepperoni and mushrooms, baked perfectly and great tasting sauce. Thanks for a great experience. Will be back soon.

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

Carnes Asadas El Chino
(248 review)
Carnes Asadas El Chino
  • Centro, 47930 Ayotlan, Jalisco, Mexico
restaurant
+52 345 918 2086
Steamers Stonewall Tavern
(1201 review)
Steamers Stonewall Tavern
  • 10078 Market St, North Lima, OH 44452, United States
seafood restaurant
+1 330-549-9041
Cafe Europa Boulevard
(896 review)
Cafe Europa Boulevard
  • Blvd. Garcia de Leon 932, Chapultepec Sur, 58200 Morelia, Mich., Mexico
cafe
Monterrey's Mexican Restaurant
(620 review)
Monterrey's Mexican Restaurant
  • 24497 Fifth Ave, Florala, AL 36442, United States
mexican restaurant
+1 334-858-2233
Mexicanisimo Restaurant 915
(401 review)
Mexicanisimo Restaurant 915
  • 9633 McCombs St, El Paso, TX 79924, United States
mexican restaurant
+1 915-694-8284
La casa verde
(163 review)
La casa verde
  • Calle Bosques De Bolognia 880, Bosques del Lago, 54766 Cuautitlán Izcalli, Méx., Mexico
mexican restaurant
Newport Vineyards & Restaurant
(765 review)
Newport Vineyards & Restaurant
  • 909 E Main Rd, Middletown, RI 02842, United States
Restaurant
+1 401-848-5161
Boston Tea Party Harborne
(2253 review)
Boston Tea Party Harborne
  • The School Yard, 106 High St, Birmingham B17 9NJ, United Kingdom
Cafe
+44 121 820 0099
Dino’s Restaurant and Lounge
(1051 review)
Dino’s Restaurant and Lounge
  • 2900 New Pinery Rd, Portage, WI 53901, United States
American restaurant
+1 608-742-4111
Fellini's Dolce Vita
(333 review)
Fellini's Dolce Vita
  • 34-36 Elm Rd, Southend-on-Sea, Leigh-on-Sea SS9 1SN, United Kingdom
italian restaurant
+44 1702 477277